Monday, March 02, 2015

On Randomness In Character Generation, and Why Old School D&D Is Awesome For New Players

So: Old school D&D is a terrible system for playing the game most people want to play when they pick up something called "D&D," not having any prior experience with old school D&D. The texts don't do a great job of communicating their purpose, and honestly, the other things that people want to do are fun and it's reasonable that they want them.

One of the big things that people want when they pick up something called "D&D" is a game where they get to craft exactly the guy that they want to play. Old school systems by and large do not deliver this, especially on a mechanical axis: Your initial character generation is random, and your advancement is usually relatively fixed and relatively random.

The thing is, most of the folks I've met like that got into the game before I got them-- middle or high school, or occasionally college. These are people who saw "fantasy adventure game" and opened it up to find that there was also a bunch of math and were super happy about it. (I'm in that camp myself-- I've had few happier days than the one where I discovered the interlocking logic of the 3e EL and XP tables.) But there's a big, big pool of people I've gotten into the game who got scared away by all that math and all those decisions, even though they desperately wanted that fantasy adventure.

But those people already get enough air time in the OSR. One of my favorite things about old school D&D is that it's made it much easier for me to run games for a mix of highly invested and brand new players than any other edition I've encountered (except maybe also 5th-- still gathering data). While really serious D&D strategists will get annoyed by the shenanigans the newer, less death-hardened players get up to, it's much easier for brand new players to contribute to the gamier side of the game than with the newer, more character-build focused versions. You don't have to read the book and absorb the rules system to play a really powerful character in old school D&D: You just have to be quick on your feet, and the right mix of careful and reckless.

Random chargen helps make generating a new character fast (important when death rates or high, or you're playing with different people every week so you need to be able to get the new guy into the game fast) and can create interesting tactical and expressive challenges for experienced players: "Well I would never choose to play this guy but now that I've got him what do I do with him?"

Fixed advancement and random advancement also make leveling easier and faster, which is important when your character is more a token that lets you interact with the game-world than an end to be developed in itself. It also really helps players who like developing their character's personality but either don't care about or actively overwhelmed by mechanical differentiation.

In general they all can make getting into D&D a lot less intimidating for new people. Generally my experience with getting brand new people into 3x/Pathfinder has been "Oh my god I have to read that entire book? Oh okay, just these bits... uh... which feats do I want... wow, it's going to take us a really long time to make all these characters, this is kind of boring." 

My experience with getting brand new people into old school D&D has been more "Oh my god I have to read that entire book? Oh, okay, just these bits... rolls stats my intelligence is really high so I guess I'll be a wizard... oh wait no, I want to be a bard, my charisma is really low but that will be hilarious."

Or even "okay, so what are all these numbers on this index card? oh, okay, you'll tell me when I need them, cool. oh, sweet, I have a grappling hook, I wonder what I can do with that."

Not that Pathfinder is a bad system for newbies-- I've played with new-ish people who expected mechanical character differentiation from video games and were disappointed/frustrated by old school games because they didn't provide that. One of the things I like about 5e is that it potentially bridges the gap between those folks and the systems I like.

The old school character generation and advancement are also fantastic for the players who want a strategic resource management game that's mostly about their lateral thinking cleverness. For those folks, choices about what widgets to give their character would be choices they weren't making about things that they care about.

22 comments:

  1. I have thought about this topic from time to time and have reached much the same conclusion. By having a random generation routine, it can level the playing field between "those who know the rule system / munchkin type players / optimizsers" and "those who are just starting / don't want to think about fiddly bits / just want to socialize".
    However, in my opinion, the old rules still suffer from a large swing in power between the results of the random tables and even in the smaller choices that are available. In Basic D&D, for example, one could pick an elf and wear armor and cast a spell and potentially roll straight 18s whereas another could pick a thief, roll 1 for hitpoints, and straight 3s for ability scores.
    Not that any of that matters in the hands of a good DM.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In the last 6 years I have had more newbie players than experienced ones, and the outcome is always the same: there's nothing better than Basic D&D to introduce people to the core concepts of the game. Apart from randomness, the fact that everyone can make mechanically meaningful choices at the table since there are so few rules is fundamental to keep a newbie interested. If a newcomer feels that he doesn't grasp something, and there's so much rules material to digest, he may feel compelled to do random choices just to start gaming, and could well feel "inadequate" in comparison with experienced players. A pet peeve of mine is the number of spell choices for some classes; even in AD&D you can't give a cleric to a newbie and expect her to "grasp" all there is to know about how to use spells, and I don't like barring a character from a player because it's too complex. With newer editions things are definitely worse (4e might be the absolute worse in this respect,) and even 5e is not exempt from this problem: all spellcasters get at least 2 or 3 cantrips, plus a few more spells, and clerics and druids suffer from the same problem as AD&D. An excellent approach is the one in Astonishing Swordsmen & Sorcerers of Hyperborea, whereas also divine spellcasters have a limited repertoire of spells.

    ReplyDelete
  3. good topic thanks for post for sharing on website ..
    หนังใหม่

    ReplyDelete
  4. Looking for Women's Fashion Items? Get the best Prices, 100% Original Products
    FNStylez is offering a wide selection of Lawn up to 25% off,FNStylez including discounts from popular brands such as charizma lawn. To determine the price discount, click on the charizma lawn collection 2019 . There are limited quantities, so make sure to explore all the options.
    This charizma lawn collection 2019 is designed to keep you looking cute, damp environments.

    From the most papular dresses to party tops and blouses etc, that follow the latest pakistani fashion trends of the season: balloon sleeves, bows in collar or cuffs and printed designs.

    Embroidered Lawn Collection 2019 Sale is on your choice branded Summer lawn suits & lawn. Unstiched Printed Lawn Suit For Women - Red Chundri... By adding latest fashion accessories at the time of stitching.

    Embroidered lawn dresses are very famous among women for they serve as a great way to portray style and elegance in a weather that makes it impossible to online shopping in lahore.

    ReplyDelete
  5. "U build Great Artikel ^_^ i already Share this artikel
    Come to my website to view the contents of my website
    BOLA PELANGI - BANDAR MIX PARLAY TERBESAR DI INDONESIA HANYA DENGAN 1 USER ID SUDAH BISA BERMAIN SEMUA GAME.
    Join US ! klik link di bawah ini ☟

    Prediksi Bola dan Togel
    Mix Parlay
    Bola Jalan
    Bandar Bola
    Bola Online
    Berita Bola
    Prediksi Parlay

    Untuk Info Dan Bonus Menariknya Bisa Hubungi Kami Di Bawah Ini :
    WHATSAPP 1 : +6282143134681
    WHATSAPP 2 : +6281333472723

    Ayo buruann , mana tau kamu menjadi jutawan setelah bergabung dengan kami .. buruann !!!

    ♛ Group FB Prediksi Parlay = https://www.facebook.com/groups/346501502486292/
    ♛ Instagram = https://www.instagram.com/bolapelangi_01/Bola Pelangi
    ♛ Pinterest = https://id.pinterest.com/bolapelangilounge/ Bolapelangi Lounge
    ✆ WA = +6282143134681 || +6281333472723"

    ReplyDelete
  6. "Come to my website to view the contents of my website
    BOLA PELANGI - BANDAR MIX PARLAY TERBESAR DI INDONESIA HANYA DENGAN 1 USER ID SUDAH BISA BERMAIN SEMUA GAME.
    Join US ! klik link di bawah ini ☟

    Prediksi Parlay Jitu
    Mix Parlay
    Bola Jalan
    U build Great Artikel ^_^ i already Share this artikel
    Bandar Bola

    Bola Online
    Berita Bola
    Prediksi Parlay

    Untuk Info Dan Bonus Menariknya Bisa Hubungi Kami Di Bawah Ini :
    WHATSAPP 1 : +6282143134681
    WHATSAPP 2 : +6281333472723

    Ayo buruann , mana tau kamu menjadi jutawan setelah bergabung dengan kami .. buruann !!!

    ♛ Group FB Prediksi Parlay = https://www.facebook.com/groups/346501502486292/
    ♛ Instagram = https://www.instagram.com/bolapelangi_01/Bola Pelangi
    ♛ Pinterest = https://id.pinterest.com/bolapelangilounge/ Bolapelangi Lounge
    ✆ WA = +6282143134681 || +6281333472723"


    ReplyDelete

  7. AWESOME !
    THATS GOOD TOPIC EVER !
    BOLAPELANGI - BANDAR MIX PARLAY TERBESAR DI INDONESIA HANYA DENGAN 1 USER ID SUDAH BISA BERMAIN SEMUA GAME.
    Prediksi Bola dan Togel.
    Mix Parlay
    Bola Jalan
    Bandar Bola
    Daftar

    ReplyDelete
  8. Công ty dịch thuật Sài Gòn là nhà cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật tại TP Hồ Chí Minh: biên dịch (dịch chuyên ngành, dịch công chứng Sài Gòn, phiên dịch chuyên nghiệp tại Lầu 6, tòa nhà becamex, 47 Điện Biên Phủ, Đakao, Quận 1, TP Hồ Chí Minh. Công ty dịch thuật Sài Gòn vinh dự và tự hào được đánh giá là địa chỉ công ty dịch thuật tiếng Hàn cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật hơn 50 ngôn ngữ khác nhau như tiếng Anh, tiếng Nhật, tiếng Trung, tiếng Pháp, tiếng Đức, tiếng Nga, tiếng Tây Ban Nha, Bồ Đào Nha, Thái Lan, Lào, Campuchia, Thụy Điển, Thổ Nhĩ Kỳ…Với phong cách làm việc nghiêm túc, chuyên nghiệp nhằm mang đến cho Quý khách hàng tại thành phố Hồ Chí Minh trải nghiệm tốt nhất trên thị trường

    ReplyDelete
  9. "Come to my website to view the contents of my website
    BOLA PELANGI - BANDAR MIX PARLAY TERBESAR DI INDONESIA HANYA DENGAN 1 USER ID SUDAH BISA BERMAIN SEMUA GAME. Join US ! klik link di bawah ini ☟
    Prediksi Parlay Jitu
    Mix Parlay
    Bola Jalan
    Bola Online
    Berita Bola


    Untuk Info Dan Bonus Menariknya Bisa Hubungi Kami Di Bawah Ini :
    WHATSAPP 1 : +6282143134681
    WHATSAPP 2 : +6281333472723
    Ayo buruann , mana tau kamu menjadi jutawan setelah bergabung dengan kami ..
    ♛ Group FB Prediksi Parlay = https://www.facebook.com/groups/346501502486292/
    ♛ Instagram = https://www.instagram.com/bolapelangi_01
    ♛ Pinterest = https://id.pinterest.com/bolapelangilounge/
    kami ..
    ♛ Group FB Prediksi Parlay = https://www.facebook.com/groups/346501502486292/
    ♛ Instagram = https://www.instagram.com/bolapelangi_01
    ♛ Pinterest = https://id.pinterest.com/bolapelangilounge/
    "

    ReplyDelete
  10. Being a vampire is not what it seems like. It’s a life full of good, and amazing things. We are as human as you are.. It’s not what you are that counts, but how you choose to be. Do you want a life full of interesting things? Do you want to have power and influence over others? To be charming and desirable? To have wealth, health, and longevity? contact the vampires creed today via email: Richvampirekindom@gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  11. after 4 years of suffering . my husband left me and my kids hated me for no reason, i got sacked at work without any genuine reasons, i shared tears daily living a lonely life but i was determined to know what is the cost of my predicament, one day as i was going through some articles on the internet i saw a testimony of mrs Vanessa testifying how she got her life revived by dr Ogbeifun the honest man and i quickly contacted him VIA ( ogbefunhearlingtemple@gmail.com ) and i explained my situation to him and he told me my ex who i broke up with to marry my husband was responsible for my misfortune and he vows to frustrate my life because i didn't marry him.
    dr Ogbeifun ask me what i wanted him to do to my ex who is after my life i told him to cast a dead spell on him because as long as he is alive he will never allow me a moment of peace , which he did and within 3 days he was dead and since his death my life have been so transformed, my kids now love me and my husband is back to me i latter got a call to return to work that the sack was a mistake , wow what a miracle .. thanks allot dr Ogbeifun. you can contact dr Ogbeifun via call or whatsapp +2348102574680 or through his email ogbefunhearlingtemple@ gmail. com

    ReplyDelete
  12. Good work.I really appreciate it.

    Infinity Limo Car is providing Limo Service DC , Dulles Limo Service.

    Book Car Service Washington DC & Car Service DC at affordable prices in Washington DC, Virginia and Maryland.

    Make your day special and avail Luxury Car Service:

    Wedding Limo Hire
    Wedding Limo Service for everyone through Washington DC, Virginia or Maryland.

    Airport Services:
    Airport Transportation near me
    Car Service DC
    Car Service Washington DC

    Services Demanded by celebrities & famous personalities:
    Hummer limo
    Hummer Limo Rental .
    Limo Rental Prices.

    Shuttle & Bus Services:
    Suburban SUV Rental
    Shuttle Service
    Limo Bus Rental

    Get Free Quote
    Reserve Limo Online Now for Luxury Tour!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Well Done! Highly recommended.

    WashingtonDC Limo Car is facilitaing with Luxury Car Service, Limo Service DC in Maryland, Virginia & Washington DC at cheap Limo Rental Prices.

    Prom Nights Service:

    Prom Limo Service ensures best Prom Limo Hire servive.
    Enjoy Cheap Limo Service.

    We are providing Airport Transfers to Washington DC, Maryland & Virginia.

    .BWI Airport Limousine And Car Service
    .BWI Car Service .BWI Limo Service.
    . Car Service to Dulles
    . IAD Car Service . Dulles Airport Limousine Service.
    . Dulles Airport Transportation
    . Car Service to Dulles.

    Book the luxury airport shuttle near you.

    Car Service Washington DC
    Airport Car Rental
    Airport Chauffeur Service to meet the demands of people traveling to and from Washington DC.

    Get Free Quote
    Reserve Limo Online Now for Luxury Tour!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Informative ideas. Keep it up!

    Vertri Limo provides one of the best Limo Service DC, Limousine Service in the Washington DC,

    Are You Looking forLimousine Service near me:

    . Cheap Limo Service
    . Prom Limo Service
    . Car Service Washington DC.

    Airport Transportation all over the Washington DC:
    Dulles Airport Transportation is the best Airport Limo Service of Vertri Limo.

    Airport Transfers service across all over the Washington DC.

    Car Service to DC
    DCA Car Service
    Limo Service DC
    Airport Transfers

    Reserve Airport Car Hire.
    Airport Shuttle Service
    Limo Airport Transfer
    limousine to airport service from Dulles, Baltimore Airport.

    Hire our Chauffeur Service
    for your luxury travel with professional Chauffeur.
    Chauffeur Car Service
    Chauffeur Service near me!



    Get Free Quote
    Reserve Limo Online for Luxury Tour!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Excellent piece of work. Superb effort!

    Airport Car Limo is serving Airport Limo Service and Airport Car Service in Washington DC.


    Airport Transportation Service provides you Airport Pickup Service to and from Reagan National Airport ,Baltimore & Dulles Airport.

    Our Airport Limousine Service are:

    Prom Limo Service
    BWI Car Service
    IAD Car Service.

    Wedding limousine Service!
    Make your Day Special with Wedding Limo, Wedding Limo Service & Wedding Limo Hire for prom nights.


    Book an Online trip to the Washington DC Airport!

    Airport Transportation Dulles
    Shuttle Service or Dulles Airport Transportation.

    Door-to-Door Airport Transportation to and from Washington DC airports including DCA, Dulles and BWI.

    DCA Airport Limo Car
    REAGAN NATIONAL AIRPORT

    Dulles Airport Transportation
    Car Service to Dulles
    IAD Airport Limo Car

    BALTIMORE AIRPORT LIMO
    Dulles Airport Taxi

    ReplyDelete